Collections Strategy · 5 min read
Writing a Demand Letter Before You Sue in Ontario Small Claims Court
Before you fill out a Form 7A Plaintiff's Claim and pay the filing fee to sue someone in Ontario, you should take one final step. You need to write a demand letter. This is a formal written notice sent to a debtor telling them exactly what they owe and giving them a hard deadline to pay before you start a lawsuit. Many people skip this step because they feel they have already asked for the money a dozen times over text or phone. But a formal demand letter serves a completely different purpose. It puts the dispute on a formal footing and shows you are serious about taking the matter to court. In our experience, a well-crafted demand letter often prompts payment without you ever having to step foot inside a courthouse. Even if it fails to get you paid, it sets up your court case perfectly by proving to a judge that you tried to resolve the issue reasonably.
The essential ingredients of your letter
The core of your letter needs to stick to the facts. You are not writing a novel about how angry you are. You are creating a clear record of the debt.
Start with the date at the top. This proves when you made the demand. Next, list the debtor's full legal name and address. If you are dealing with a business, make sure you use their correct registered corporate name.
State the exact amount owed right away. Do not leave them guessing. After that, provide a very brief summary of why the money is owed. You might say that it is for unpaid invoices related to landscaping work completed in July, or for a personal loan you gave them last year. Attach copies of any relevant documents. If you have an unpaid invoice or a signed contract, put a copy in the envelope. Do not send your original documents.
Finally, state clearly that if payment is not received by your deadline, you will commence a lawsuit in the Ontario Small Claims Court without further notice.
Keep the tone strictly professional
It is very tempting to let your frustration spill onto the page. When someone owes you money and avoids your calls, you naturally feel disrespected.
Keep your emotions entirely out of it.
Your tone should be firm, professional, and completely objective. Name-calling or aggressive threats will only make the other person defensive. It can also backfire terribly if the matter actually ends up in court. Remember that a judge or a deputy judge might read this letter later. You want to look like the reasonable professional in the room. The person who owes you money should look like the one acting unreasonably by ignoring a polite, factual request for payment.
Setting a realistic deadline for payment
A demand letter is useless if it does not include a firm deadline. Giving a deadline forces the debtor to make a decision.
A standard deadline is 10 to 15 days from the date of the letter. This gives the person enough time to receive the mail, check their bank account, and arrange payment. Giving them 24 hours is rarely effective and looks unreasonable to a judge. Giving them 30 days simply drags the process out too long.
State exactly how you want to be paid. If you want an e-transfer, provide the email address. If you want a certified cheque, give them the exact mailing address. Make it as easy as possible for them to hand over the money. If the deadline passes and your bank account is still empty, you know it is time to move forward with drafting your claim.
A real example of a demand letter working
Let us look at a practical situation. We regularly see cases like this in our Grimsby office.
Imagine a local contractor who did a basement renovation for a homeowner. The job went well, but the homeowner held back the final $8,000 payment. The contractor sent text messages for two months and got nothing but excuses about tight finances. The contractor was ready to head straight to the courthouse.
Instead, they sent a formal demand letter by registered mail. The letter stated the $8,000 balance, referenced the original contract, attached the final invoice, and gave a 15-day deadline before a Small Claims Court lawsuit would begin.
The homeowner realized the contractor was no longer just complaining over text. The threat of a public lawsuit and the potential damage to their credit forced their hand. On day 14, the contractor received an e-transfer for the full amount. This saved the contractor the time of drafting a claim, the cost of court filing fees, and months of waiting for a settlement conference or trial.
How the letter protects you in court
Sometimes the debtor will ignore the letter entirely. When that happens, you have to follow through and file your Form 7A Plaintiff's Claim. The Small Claims Court limit in Ontario is $50,000, so any amount up to that cap can be pursued this way.
Even though the letter did not get you paid immediately, it still helps your legal case tremendously. Under the Rules of the Small Claims Court, judges care about whether parties tried to settle the matter before taking up court resources.
When you attach your demand letter to your claim, it proves you acted in good faith. It shows you gave the defendant every opportunity to avoid litigation. This can actually help you when it comes time for the judge to award costs at the end of a trial. If the defendant ignored your reasonable demands, the judge may be more inclined to award you a higher amount for your legal expenses.
Writing a demand letter might seem like a chore when you are already frustrated. But it is a necessary foundation for any smart collection strategy. If you need help drafting a strong letter or preparing your claim, Robertson Legal Services offers a free consultation to review your situation.
Bottom line
A demand letter is your final attempt to collect a debt before starting a lawsuit. Keep it factual, set a firm 10 to 15 day deadline, and use it to build a strong foundation for your court case if the debtor refuses to pay.
Information only, not professional advice. Laws, monetary limits and court fees change — confirm current figures with Ontario Court Services or speak to a licensed paralegal or lawyer about your situation.