← All articles

    Costs & Limits · 5 min read

    Getting Your Costs Back in Ontario Small Claims Court

    You win your Small Claims Court case and get a judgment for the money you are owed. But what about the money you spent to get that judgment? People always ask us if they can force the losing side to pay their legal bills. The short answer is yes. You can usually recover a portion of your costs. But you will almost never get every single penny back. Ontario Small Claims Court is designed to be relatively affordable. To keep the system accessible, the rules strictly limit how much a winning party can demand in legal costs from the losing party. Understanding these limits before you start your lawsuit will help you make smart financial decisions along the way.

    Getting Your Disbursements Back

    We need to split court costs into two different categories. The first category is disbursements. Disbursements are your exact out-of-pocket expenses that you pay to third parties just to move your case forward.

    When you file a Form 7A Plaintiff's Claim, the court charges a filing fee. If you hire a private process server to hand that claim to the defendant, the process server charges a fee. If the defendant files a Form 9A Defence and you eventually need to book a trial date, the court charges another fee to set the action down for trial.

    These are all standard disbursements. If you win your case, the judge will normally order the unsuccessful party to pay you back for these basic expenses. The court clerk will also add these basic disbursements to your total if you obtain a Form 11A Default Judgment when a defendant simply ignores your claim.

    You should always keep your receipts for everything. Process server invoices and court fee receipts are mandatory if you want the judge or the clerk to add them to your final judgment. Court fees change periodically. You should always check the current Ontario court fee schedule online to see the exact dollar amounts for filing and scheduling.

    The 15 Percent Cap on Representation Fees

    The second category is representation fees. This is the money you pay to a licensed paralegal or a lawyer to draft your documents and argue your case in court.

    This is where creditors usually get surprised. In higher courts, a winning party might recover a huge chunk of their legal bills. Small Claims Court operates under a very specific restriction found in the Courts of Justice Act.

    The law states that the successful party cannot be awarded more than 15 percent of the total amount claimed for their representation fees.

    This means the amount you can recover for your paralegal fees is directly tied to the size of your lawsuit. It has absolutely nothing to do with how many hours your legal representative actually worked on your file. If your case is highly complex and requires multiple days in court, your actual legal bill might be quite high. The judge is still bound by that strict 15 percent mathematical ceiling for the cost award.

    The only things excluded from that 15 percent cap are the basic out-of-pocket disbursements we talked about earlier. You get the approved representation fees plus your allowable disbursements.

    A Practical Example of the Math

    Let us look at a real scenario we see often. Imagine a local independent contractor who finishes a basement renovation. The homeowner refuses to pay the final invoice. The contractor is owed exactly $8,000.

    The contractor hires a paralegal to sue the homeowner. They go all the way to trial and the contractor wins completely. The judge orders the homeowner to pay the $8,000 debt.

    Now the judge calculates the costs. The claim was for $8,000. Fifteen percent of $8,000 is $1,200. The absolute maximum the judge can award the contractor for their paralegal fees is $1,200.

    Let us say the contractor spent $350 on court filing fees and process server invoices along the way.

    The final judgment will be the $8,000 debt, plus the $1,200 in representation costs, plus the $350 in disbursements. The homeowner owes a total of $9,550. If the contractor actually paid their paralegal $2,500 to run the whole trial, the contractor will have to absorb that difference. This is why we always sit down with our clients to do a realistic cost-benefit analysis before filing a claim. Sometimes fighting over a very small amount of money simply does not make financial sense once you factor in unrecoverable legal fees.

    The Strategic Use of Offers to Settle

    There is one major exception to the normal limits. The Rules of the Small Claims Court are designed to encourage people to settle their disputes without taking up valuable court time. Rule 14 contains powerful cost consequences relating to formal offers to settle.

    You can serve the other side with a formal written Offer to Settle at almost any time before the trial. If you make a reasonable offer and the other side ignores it, they are taking a massive risk.

    If a plaintiff makes an offer to settle and then beats their own offer at trial, the court can penalize the defendant. Beating your own offer means the judge awards you an amount that is equal to or greater than what you were willing to accept to drop the case. When this happens, the judge can order the defendant to pay double the normal representation costs.

    Using our previous example of the $8,000 debt, the normal maximum representation fee was $1,200. If the contractor made a valid Rule 14 offer early on to settle for $7,000 and the homeowner ignored it, the judge could double the maximum costs to $2,400.

    Defendants can use this rule too. If a defendant makes a reasonable offer to pay a certain amount and the plaintiff refuses, the plaintiff might win the trial but still get penalized. If the judge awards the plaintiff less than what the defendant offered, the plaintiff might be ordered to pay the defendant's costs from the date the offer was made.

    Exceptions for Unreasonable Behaviour

    Judges do have a tiny bit of extra discretion when people behave terribly. If a party acts in a way that is entirely unreasonable or in bad faith, the court can award additional costs.

    Unreasonable behaviour might mean hiding documents or lying to the court. It might mean requesting multiple last-minute adjournments just to delay the process. If someone drags out a lawsuit out of pure spite, the judge can step outside the normal 15 percent limit to compensate the innocent party for the wasted time.

    You should never count on this happening. Proving bad faith is difficult. Judges reserve these special cost awards for extreme situations.

    The rules around court costs and limits do change from time to time. You should always confirm the current rules and the current court fee schedules before you start a lawsuit. If you are unsure about whether your claim is worth pursuing financially, please reach out to our office. Robertson Legal Services offers a free initial consultation to help you understand your options.

    Bottom line

    You can generally recover your out-of-pocket disbursements and up to 15 percent of your claim amount for legal representation in Small Claims Court. Using formal offers to settle can sometimes increase your cost award if the other side refuses a reasonable deal.

    Information only, not professional advice. Laws, monetary limits and court fees change — confirm current figures with Ontario Court Services or speak to a licensed paralegal or lawyer about your situation.