← All articles

    Court Process · 6 min read

    How to Prepare for an Ontario Small Claims Settlement Conference

    You have filed your Form 7A Plaintiff's Claim. The defendant filed a Form 9A Defence. You might be wondering when you actually get to stand in front of a judge and argue your case. In Ontario Small Claims Court, your first stop is not a trial. It is a mandatory settlement conference. The purpose of a settlement conference is exactly what it sounds like. The court wants to see if the parties can settle the lawsuit without going to a full trial. Trials take up a lot of court resources and cost everyone involved a lot of money. A deputy judge will meet with you and the other party in a private setting. This is a chance to speak frankly about the strengths and weaknesses of the case. In our experience, many cases resolve right here. Being prepared for this step is the best way to protect your interests and get a fair result.

    The Real Purpose of the Meeting

    A settlement conference is an informal, confidential meeting. It is not a trial. You will not be swearing on a Bible, and you will not be cross-examining witnesses.

    Instead, you sit at a table (or join a Zoom call) with the defendant and a deputy judge. The judge has read your claim and the defendant's defence. They will ask both sides to explain their view of the dispute.

    This environment is designed to encourage conversation. The judge is there to mediate the discussion. They will often point out the risks each side faces if the matter goes to trial. They give an honest, neutral opinion of the case based on the documents filed so far.

    Everything said at a settlement conference is strictly confidential. If you admit a weakness in your case to try and reach a compromise, the other side cannot use that statement against you at a future trial. The judge who hears your settlement conference is also not allowed to preside over your trial. This rule exists so that everyone can speak openly without fear of ruining their case.

    Disclosure and What You Must Bring

    You cannot just show up and expect the judge to take your word for everything. You have to back up your claims with evidence.

    Under the Rules of the Small Claims Court, you are required to disclose all documents you intend to rely on at trial. You must serve these documents on every other party and file them with the court at least 14 days before the settlement conference. If you do not provide this disclosure on time, the judge might adjourn the conference and order you to pay the other party's costs for the wasted day.

    What should you bring? Bring copies of any contracts, unpaid invoices, text messages, and email chains. You must also prepare and serve a list of the witnesses you plan to call if the case goes to trial.

    Do not try to hide a "smoking gun" document for a dramatic reveal at trial. Civil litigation does not work like television. The rules require upfront disclosure. If you surprise the other side with a new document at trial, the trial judge will likely refuse to let you use it. Sharing your best evidence before the settlement conference actually helps you. It shows the other side and the judge exactly how strong your case is. This makes a favorable settlement much more likely.

    A Practical Example of Good Preparation

    Let us look at a realistic example to see how this plays out in practice. Imagine you are a general contractor in Ontario. You are owed $8,000 for a basement renovation you completed last year. You filed your claim, and the homeowner filed a defence saying the work was defective.

    At the settlement conference, the homeowner complains that you used the wrong type of flooring. If you come prepared, you can pull out an email chain where the homeowner explicitly approved that exact flooring material.

    The deputy judge will see that email. They will likely turn to the homeowner and point out that a trial judge will see the exact same email. The judge might explain to the homeowner that their defence looks very weak and that losing at trial could mean paying the $8,000 plus court costs and interest.

    Because you organized your documents and served them properly, the judge was able to use your evidence to pressure the defendant. In a situation like this, the homeowner will often agree to pay the debt (or a very close amount) right then and there.

    Approaching Offers and Negotiation

    You should walk into the settlement conference with an open mind. Be prepared to negotiate.

    Very few cases are guaranteed wins. Even if you have strong evidence, going to trial involves risk. A trial means taking time away from your business. It means paying more legal fees. It also means dealing with the stress of testifying.

    Think about what your bottom line is before the conference begins. If you are owed $10,000, would you accept $8,500 today just to have the matter finished? You need to weigh the value of a guaranteed, immediate payment against the uncertainty of a trial that might be scheduled many months away.

    Listen carefully to the deputy judge. They are experienced lawyers who sit as part-time judges. If they tell you that a part of your claim is weak, you should take that feedback seriously. Adjust your settlement expectations based on their comments. Do not let stubbornness get in the way of a good deal.

    What the Judge Can Actually Do

    A deputy judge has a lot of influence, but their power at a settlement conference has limits.

    The judge cannot force anyone to settle. If the defendant completely refuses to pay, the judge cannot enter a judgment against them right then. The only way to get a judgment without consent at this stage is if a party fails to show up entirely.

    If you and the defendant do reach an agreement, the judge will write out a consent order. This is a binding court order. If the defendant agrees to pay you $5,000 in monthly installments and then misses a payment, you can take that order and start using enforcement methods. You could file a garnishment or direct the bailiff to seize property.

    If no settlement is reached, the judge will make orders to get the case ready for trial. They might order a deadline for final document disclosure. They will estimate how many days the trial will take. After the conference, you can request a trial date from the clerk.

    Keep in mind that court fees change from time to time. You will need to pay a fee to set the matter down for trial. Always check the current Ontario court fee schedule online before filing your request.

    Preparing for a settlement conference can feel overwhelming, but you do not have to do it by yourself. If you need help reviewing your documents or negotiating with a difficult defendant, reach out to us. Robertson Legal Services offers a free consultation to discuss your Small Claims Court matter.

    Bottom line

    A settlement conference is your best opportunity to resolve an Ontario Small Claims Court dispute without the stress and cost of a trial. Proper preparation and upfront disclosure give you a massive advantage in negotiations. Listen to the judge, keep an open mind, and focus on practical solutions.

    Information only, not professional advice. Laws, monetary limits and court fees change — confirm current figures with Ontario Court Services or speak to a licensed paralegal or lawyer about your situation.